Go-To Guides(1,231)
Pin It(190)
Rooms We Love(1,162)
Top Rated(2,934)
Bed & Bath(49)
Dining & Entertaining(1,159)
Furniture(432)
Kitchen & Food(953)
Organizing & Storage(109)
What You Need To...(1,799)
Choose a Category
- Shop Bed & Bath
- Shop Business Sales
- Shop Clean Slate
- Shop Decorating & Accessories
- Shop Dining & Entertaining
- Shop Father's Day
- Shop Furniture
- Shop Gift Ideas
- Shop Halloween
- Shop Ideas & Inspiration
- Shop Kitchen & Food
- Shop Organizing & Storage
- Shop Outdoor Living
- Shop Outlet
- Shop Registry Ideas
- Shop Sale
- Shop Special Features
- Shop Store Events
- Shop Thanksgiving
- Shop The Marimekko Shop
- Shop Valentine's Day
- Shop What's New
Top-Rated Products
Customer Reviews for Homemade Cookie Jar
Homemade Cookie Jar
Inspired by a mid-century kitchen jar, this heartwarming crock promises fresh homemade cookies in raised-relief writing. Cookie jar with tight-sealing lid is hand-carved and -sculpted in glossy white stoneware. -Hand carved and sculpted stoneware -Rubber lid gasket -Dishwasher-, microwave- and oven-safe to 300 degrees -Made in China
Average Rating
(41 Reviews) 41
Rating Snapshot (41 reviews)
5 stars
30
4 stars
6
3 stars
2
2 stars
2
1 star
1
Number of reviews: 41 Reviews
37 of 41(90%)customers would
recommend this product to a friend.
recommend this product to a friend.
Customer Reviews for Homemade Cookie Jar
Review 1 for Homemade Cookie Jar
Overall Rating
Jen Leigh
Dwelling:house
Style:classic
Heard about Reviews from:Website
Purchased from:Website
Would you recommend this product? Yes
Date: March 5, 2013
Adorable, Classic Cookie Jar
"This cookie jar looks great on my kitchen counter, and I love filling it with my homemade cookies. It's durable, a good size, and washes well."
2 of 2 people found this review helpful.
Share this Review?
Review 2 for Homemade Cookie Jar
Overall Rating
Lreader
Location:Western Florida
Dwelling:townhouse
Style:traditional
Heard about Reviews from:Email
Purchased from:Website
Would you recommend this product? Yes
Date: March 4, 2013
Simplicity in the Kitchen
"Remember the smell of cookies baking in the oven or the taste of a warm gooey cookie just out of the oven. This stylish cookie jar brings those memories back to all who see it. I shared this with friends at Christmas filled with candy, cookies and brownies. Add a grosgain red or green ribbon around the top, just below the lid, and off she goes. I also kept one for myself because the style and color goes with every decor. I have had several friends ask if it was an old one."
Share this Review?
Review 3 for Homemade Cookie Jar
Overall Rating
ESPB
Location:Evanston, IL
Dwelling:house
Style:classic
Heard about Reviews from:Email
Purchased from:Store
Would you recommend this product? Yes
Date: March 4, 2013
Great look
"This is a great cookie jar with a cute, yet functional design. I like the nostalgic look of it. The opening is nice and big, so even large cookies can fit inside. There are no nooks and crannies with such a straight-forward design, so cleaning is a breeze. I bought this in-store and noticed that not all the lids fit flush with the jar. Thankfully, I found one I was happy with. I suppose the irregularity is part of the aesthetic, so it's possible this wouldn't bother anyone else."
1 of 1 people found this review helpful.
Share this Review?
Review 4 for Homemade Cookie Jar
Overall Rating
LRod102
Location:Philadelphia, PA
Dwelling:house
Style:contemporary
Heard about Reviews from:Email
Purchased from:Website
Would you recommend this product? Yes
Date: March 4, 2013
We love this cookie jar!
"I had been looking for a cookie jar that would hold a nice amount of cookies and have that "old fashioned" feel in a modern home. I came across this and couldn't be happier. It warms up my kitchen and I would recommend it to anyone in the market for a cookie jar."
Share this Review?
Review 5 for Homemade Cookie Jar
Overall Rating
Kate in MadCity
Location:Madison, WI
Dwelling:house
Style:classic
Heard about Reviews from:Website
Purchased from:Website
Would you recommend this product? Yes
Date: March 4, 2013
Awesome
"Love this cookie jar! A classic that goes with any decor! Only issue is the lid is very tight and requires you to hold the jar to remove it."
1 of 1 people found this review helpful.
Share this Review?
Review 6 for Homemade Cookie Jar
Overall Rating
Anonymous
Location:Madison, GA
Dwelling:house
Style:contemporary
Heard about Reviews from:Email
Purchased from:Store
Would you recommend this product? Yes
Date: March 4, 2013
Great Cookie Jar
"I love how simple this cookie jar, but you can still easily read the text. I'm looking forward to eating cookies from this jar for years to come."
Share this Review?
Review 7 for Homemade Cookie Jar
Overall Rating
Anonymous
Location:Orange County, CA
Dwelling:apartment/condo
Style:classic
Heard about Reviews from:Email
Purchased from:Store
Would you recommend this product? Yes
Date: March 4, 2013
Love this!
"The look and style of this cookie jar is perfect for my kitchen. It's a great size to keep out on your counter and holds a couple dozen cookies. My husband loves having it full of fresh baked cookies! Keeps them fresh for about 5 days."
Share this Review?
Review 8 for Homemade Cookie Jar
Overall Rating
joeydee19
Location:ny, ny
Dwelling:house
Style:traditional
Heard about Reviews from:Email
Purchased from:Website
Would you recommend this product? Yes
Date: April 9, 2013
Excellent purchase
"Love this cookie jar...very satisfied with this purchase!"
1 of 1 people found this review helpful.
Share this Review?
Review 9 for Homemade Cookie Jar
Overall Rating
CoreyP
Location:Lisle, IL
Dwelling:townhouse
Style:classic
Heard about Reviews from:Email
Purchased from:Website
Would you recommend this product? No
Date: February 22, 2013
Needs a better seal
"Really like the look and size of this jar but it does not seal very well."
Share this Review?
Review 10 for Homemade Cookie Jar
Overall Rating
Jamig
Location:Portland, OR
Dwelling:house
Style:classic
Heard about Reviews from:Website
Purchased from:Store
Would you recommend this product? Yes
Date: December 27, 2012
Absolutely THRILLED!!!
"I've been looking for a simple (understated, yet cute) cookie jar with a seal for years. This is the first I've found that didn't cost an arm & a leg and I LOVE the old fashioned/handmade styling!
This is definitely one of those things you're better off getting in person as each one is different. Some had a lot of imperfections in the stoneware itself and also some were not straight across the top (some lids also were wavy), resulting in a bad seal. Keep in mind... they are advertised as Hand Carved/Sculpted, so I guess this is to be expected as they are not uniformly machine-made. I picked through them to find mine that had a flush fitting lid, allowing for the seal to fit tightly. The cookies seem to keep fresh up to 3 days (guess that also depends on how often you open the lid & allow more air flow?), which is similar to a zip lock bag for me."
2 of 2 people found this review helpful.
Share this Review?
Review 11 for Homemade Cookie Jar
Overall Rating
LaykasMimi
Location:Destin Florida
Dwelling:house
Style:traditional
Heard about Reviews from:Website
Purchased from:Website
Would you recommend this product? Yes
Date: February 8, 2013
Home made Cookie Jar
"I wasn't sure if this was really what I was looking for when I wanted a cookie jar but I ordered it and love it. Some comments stated that the lid did not fit tightly but I find that it does. I really do like it. My only problem is keeping it filled with my home made cookies!"
1 of 1 people found this review helpful.
Share this Review?
Review 12 for Homemade Cookie Jar
Overall Rating
cookiebookie
Would you recommend this product? Yes
Date: January 20, 2013
I am impressed
"looked for a special cookie jar for a friend and when I saw this, I knew I had found it. I was so pleased when it arrived to see that it was even better than the picture!"
Share this Review?
Review 13 for Homemade Cookie Jar
Overall Rating
Foodie64
Style:classic
Heard about Reviews from:Website
Purchased from:Website
Would you recommend this product? Yes
Date: December 26, 2012
Great Cookie Jar
"A beautiful addition to the kitchen counter. The cookie jar was exactly as pictured and holds a good amount. Thanks Crate and Barrel for another lovely product!"
Share this Review?
Review 14 for Homemade Cookie Jar
Overall Rating
Lreader
Location:Florida
Dwelling:townhouse
Style:traditional
Heard about Reviews from:Email
Purchased from:Website
Would you recommend this product? Yes
Date: December 7, 2012
Perfect Cookie Jar
"This smaller version of Americana cookie jars is perfectfor today's diet-conscious families. Holds a package of Oreos or Chips A Hoy, but not enough cookies to widen the waistline. It is lovely sitting on the kitchen counter and I ordered 4 for Christmas, including one for myself. Fill it, then tie a red ribbon on and you are set to go. If I need more gifts, I will definitely consider purchasing more."
Share this Review?
Review 15 for Homemade Cookie Jar
Overall Rating
PeacePetty
Location:Indiana
Dwelling:house
Style:classic
Heard about Reviews from:Email
Purchased from:Website
Would you recommend this product? Yes
Date: December 6, 2012
Perfect Cookie Jar
"This cookie jar is great! It is the perfect size for any kind of cookie you want to store. It is so beautiful in person. Nice and heavy. I think it would be a great addition to anyone's kitchen!"
Share this Review?
Review 16 for Homemade Cookie Jar
Overall Rating
najakitty
Location:Tampa
Dwelling:apartment/condo
Style:traditional
Heard about Reviews from:Review Giveaway
Purchased from:Website
Would you recommend this product? Yes
Date: September 10, 2012
Mom Loved It
"Ordered this for my mother and she loves it. The seal on it was snug so no problems there and it was packaged very well with no damage."
2 of 2 people found this review helpful.
Share this Review?
Review 17 for Homemade Cookie Jar
Overall Rating
LaMor522
Location:Round Rock TX
Dwelling:house
Style:contemporary
Heard about Reviews from:Email
Purchased from:Website
Would you recommend this product? Yes
Date: September 8, 2012
awesome cookie jar
"It keeps the cookies fresh for over a week. Has a very tight seal. Great to keep other pastries fresh also, or even for dog biscuits!"
3 of 3 people found this review helpful.
Share this Review?
Review 18 for Homemade Cookie Jar
Overall Rating
Teppie
Location:Frisco, TX
Dwelling:apartment/condo
Heard about Reviews from:Review Giveaway
Purchased from:Store
Would you recommend this product? Yes
Date: September 8, 2012
Mmmm... Cookies!
"I'm not going to lie, when I received this as a wedding gift I made chocolate chip cookies just so I could use it! We just love it. Anytime people come to our home and see the jar they always comment on how awesome it looks. :)"
1 of 1 people found this review helpful.
Share this Review?
Review 19 for Homemade Cookie Jar
Overall Rating
NICKS MOM
Location:Northern California
Dwelling:house
Style:traditional
Heard about Reviews from:Email
Purchased from:Website
Would you recommend this product? Yes
Date: September 21, 2012
Cute as the picture
"I read the dimensions, but it still looks a little larger than I'd anticipated. I was glad that it looked at least big enough to hold a batch of cookies. I paired this with a Christmas cookbook for a December birthday gift.
Cute. I'd like to keep it for myself."
Cute. I'd like to keep it for myself."
Share this Review?
Review 20 for Homemade Cookie Jar
Overall Rating
CMFTS
Location:Oregon
Dwelling:apartment/condo
Style:contemporary
Purchased from:Website
Would you recommend this product? Yes
Date: July 25, 2012
My first cookie jar!
"I have never owned a cookie jar and this one was adorable and made the cut. It's nice and sturdy and holds a lot of cookies. Looks great displayed in my kitchen."
1 of 1 people found this review helpful.
Share this Review?